主演：大卫·休里斯 / 伊莲娜·雅各布 / 迈克尔·因佩里奥利 / Sophie Auster
导演：保罗·奥斯特
语言：英语
地区: 西班牙 / 葡萄牙 / 法国 / 美国
编剧：保罗·奥斯特
类型：剧情 / 喜剧 / 奇幻
上映时间：2007-02-10
别名：在马丁森林内的生活
用户标签：美国,PaulAuster,保罗·奥斯特,美国电影,David_Thewlis,Paul_Auster,法国,欧洲
片长：USA: 94 分钟 / Germany: 94 分钟(European Film Market)
imdb编号：tt0479074

what motivated me up to the new director's festival to catch 'martin frost' tonight was the brutal review that it got yesterday from the lead critic of the new york times, brutal dismissal, to be more accurate, 'the less said about (it) the better', she said, and i figured that any movie able to teach Ms Dargis the virtue of silence for even a few column inches would be worth the trip.
　　and worth the trip it was. we are brought into a paradise of limpidly beautiful visual textures. the oaken rhythms of a country house ensconced in a springtime parkland of luxuriant trees and luminous skies bestow the soothing natural blessing needed by the main character, martin frost (David Thewlis), a writer rubbed raw by the mechanics of finishing a novel in new york city. (Thewlis makes palpable the casualty of intrapsychic machinery sawed into daemonic reverb against the banausic hive). then paradise morphs into purgatory, leavened comedically, in Dante's sense, by the postmodern angelic visitations of Claire (Irene Jacobs) and Anna (Sophie Auster).
　　unfortunately, to my taste, the verbal dimensions of the film are flaccid, the logic more fanciful than imaginative, the narrative arc crippled by some irredeemably creaky plotting, especially at the crucial initiation of the relationship between martin and Claire where the seeds of common sense are thrown to the magpies of theatricality.
　　but so beguiling is the willful vulnerability of auster's fantasy, and the edgy interplay that it potentiates between Thewlis and Jacobs, and the camera, and later Sophie Auster, and the broad comedy of a rural everyman (Michael Imperioli), that it is very pleasant to be carried along on the visual foam of uncertain sensual delight, eddying into a feeling that this film's oddly louche light touch is uniquely adept at tracing some grave lineaments of the human heart.
　　go innocently.

《马丁·弗罗斯特的内心生活电影网友评论》

一直喜欢有关艺术家创作的文艺作品，保罗·奥斯特是我喜爱的作家，但这部他执导的电影非常糟糕。影片毫无框架和灵魂可言，所有关于作家创作的内容和思路陈词滥调到极点，简单薄气，乏味无聊。那部#烟#就一般，但这部令我厌恶起他的电影作品。希望他别拍#幻影书#，别毁了一部好作品。雅各布的表演太差了

就算奥斯特多多少少是一个蛮糟糕的导演??这部电影里还是有不少有意思的地方：他的女儿苏菲·奥斯特有趣的表演（还有清唱！）＋迈克尔的搞笑段落。IreneJacob做缪思就有点太老啦！（ps.DVD里有段50分钟的奥斯特采访，似乎比正片好看，哈哈哈）

情欲版《恋恋书中人》，关键是《幻影书》里的不是黑白默片剧本么！不是一个看上去可以被各种过度解读的故事么！怎么变小清新了！【卢平教授倒是真的很有作家气质

写成小说也许更好看，拍成电影只能暴露出奥斯特的手法稚嫩，这种题材要么干脆交给林奇或科恩那种变态才会闪光吧，==，要不是看伊莲娜根本看不下去

仰天长笑（又看烂片（真想去读读他的书看看是不是也是类似的cliche（为什么thewlis的床戏总是一个姿势ugh

1.10年前的伊莲娜雅各布就已经老了；2.保罗奥斯特先生请好好写小说。

以为是传说中的作家诗意电影，咋就变成没头没尾的sf了……

將一段毫無內容的敘事擴充到一個半小時

作品，镜中可见，反射

一封寫給謬絲的情書。

/